How to Appeal a Medicare Decision
General information only — not legal advice, and not a substitute for the notice in your hand. Every deadline and dollar amount on this page comes from the government's own booklet, Medicare Appeals (CMS Product No. 11525), read in full for this page. The dollar amounts are the booklet's 2026 figures — they change over time. Your own denial notice prints the deadline and the address that apply to you. If the date on your notice and a date on this page ever differ, follow your notice.
First: how do you get your Medicare?
There are three doors, and your appeal starts at a different one depending on your coverage:
- Door 1 — Original Medicare (Part A and Part B, the red-white-and-blue card). Your claims show up on a paper called the Medicare Summary Notice.
- Door 2 — A Medicare health plan, such as a Medicare Advantage Plan. A private company runs your coverage.
- Door 3 — A Medicare drug plan (Part D). This door is for prescription drugs only.
Find your door below. Levels 3, 4, and 5 are the same for all three doors, and they are explained once, further down.
Door 1: Original Medicare
- Find the Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) for the service. It comes by mail at least every 6 months. If you chose electronic notices, a new one comes every month. It lists what was billed, what Medicare paid, and what you may owe.
- Read the appeal information on the notice. The MSN tells you how to appeal and where to send it. Ask your doctor or provider for any information that supports your case, and keep copies of everything you send.
- Start Level 1 — a "redetermination." Circle the item you disagree with on a copy of the MSN and send it to the Medicare contractor named on the notice. You can also use Form CMS-20027, or write a letter with your name, your Medicare Number, the item and its date, why you disagree, and proof if someone is representing you. Send it by the date shown on your notice. If you miss the date and you have a good reason — the booklet calls this "good cause" — explain the reason in writing and ask for more time.
- Wait for the Level 1 answer. The contractor generally decides within about 60 days. Each time you send in more information, the clock can grow by 14 days.
- If Level 1 still says no, go to Level 2. Ask the Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) — named in your Level 1 decision letter — for a "reconsideration." Your request is due within 180 days of the date on the Level 1 decision letter. Form CMS-20033 is the form for this. The answer generally comes in about 60 days.
About a warning notice you may have signed. If a provider gave you an Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage (Form CMS-R-131) before the service, your choice on that form matters. If you picked Option 1 — you wanted the service and wanted Medicare billed — your appeal rights are intact. If you picked Option 2 or 3, the booklet says there is no appeal for that item, because Medicare was never billed or you did not take the service. Similar notices exist for nursing facility care (Form CMS-10055), hospital stays, and home health care — each one explains its own appeal path.
Door 2: A Medicare health plan (Medicare Advantage)
Before you can appeal, the plan must first make its decision — called an organization determination. If the plan says no to care or to a payment, here is the path:
- Start Level 1 — ask the plan to look again. This is called asking for a reconsideration. Your request is due within 65 days of the date on the plan's denial notice.
- Know how fast the plan must answer. If you have not gotten the care yet: generally 30 days. For a payment you already made: 60 days. For Part B drugs: 7 days. For a fast appeal: 72 hours. In some cases the plan may take up to 14 extra days, and it must tell you if it does.
- If the plan still says no, Level 2 happens on its own. The plan must send your case to an Independent Review Entity (IRE) — reviewers who do not work for the plan. You do not have to send it yourself. The same time limits apply at Level 2.
If waiting could seriously harm your health, ask for a fast ("expedited") decision. At the first decision stage, the booklet's clocks are 24 hours for Part B drugs and 72 hours for items and services when your health could be seriously jeopardized by waiting.
Door 3: A Medicare drug plan (Part D)
- Start at the pharmacy. If your drug is not covered, you get a written notice at the pharmacy ("Medicare Drug Coverage and Your Rights").
- Talk with the doctor who prescribed the drug. They may switch you to a covered drug, or support your request to the plan.
- Ask the plan for a "coverage determination." That is the plan's decision about covering your drug. You can also ask for an exception — to cover a drug that is not on the plan's list, to charge you a lower price tier, or to set aside a rule like prior approval. A standard answer is due in 72 hours; an exception answer is due 72 hours after your doctor's supporting statement arrives. For a drug you already paid for, the answer is due in 14 days. If waiting could seriously jeopardize your health, ask for the fast track: 24 hours. The fast track is not available if you already paid for the drug.
- If the plan says no, start Level 1 — ask the plan to look again ("redetermination"), within 65 days of the denial notice. Fast answers come in 72 hours; other drug requests in 7 days; payment requests in 14 days.
- If the plan still says no, go to Level 2 — the Independent Review Entity — within 65 days of the plan's Level 1 notice, with the same answer clocks. If your case is about the plan's drug management program (limits placed on certain drugs for safety), the plan must send your case to Level 2 on its own.
Levels 3, 4, and 5 — the same for every door
- Level 3 — a judge hearing. You ask the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals for a hearing with an Administrative Law Judge, within 60 days of the Level 2 decision. The amount you are disputing must reach $200 in 2026 — you may add claims together to reach it. Hearings are usually held by phone or video. The request form is OMHA-100.
- Level 4 — the Medicare Appeals Council. You ask within 60 days of the Level 3 decision. There is no minimum dollar amount at this level. The request form is DAB-101.
- Level 5 — federal court. You ask a federal district court to review the case, within 60 days of the Council's decision. The amount must reach $1,960 in 2026, and you can only go to court if the Council decided against you or did not decide in time.
If your care is ending too soon — the fast appeal
This is a different, faster path for a common problem: a hospital or facility says your Medicare-covered care is ending, and you believe it is too soon.
- In a hospital: you get a notice called the "Important Message from Medicare." You can ask the Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO) — independent reviewers for Medicare — for a fast review. Ask by the deadline day printed on your notice (no later than the day you are discharged). While the BFCC-QIO decides, you stay, and you do not pay for the extra time beyond your normal deductible and coinsurance. The reviewers generally decide within 1 day of getting the needed information.
- In other settings (a skilled nursing facility, home health, hospice, or a rehabilitation facility): you get a notice at least 2 days before your care ends. Ask the BFCC-QIO for a fast review by noon on the day before the end date. The reviewers generally decide by the close of business the day after they get the needed information.
- Observation status: if the hospital changes you from an inpatient to an outpatient under "observation," that change has its own fast appeal, using a notice called the Medicare Change of Status Notice (Form CMS-10868). A decision generally takes about 2 days. This matters because inpatient status affects your Part A deductible and whether Medicare can cover skilled nursing care afterward.
The phone number for your BFCC-QIO is printed on the notices above. The two organizations that do this work for Medicare are Livanta and Acentra — which one covers you depends on your state.
Help — and having someone appeal for you
- Free help: your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) gives free, local counseling to people with Medicare, including help filing an appeal. Find yours at shiphelp.org, or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048.
- A representative: a family member, friend, lawyer, or other person can act for you if you appoint them — use Form CMS-1696, or send a written request with the information the form asks for. For some plan and drug requests, your doctor can act for you without that form.
- A complaint is not an appeal. If your problem is about how you were treated, long waits, or the quality of your care — not about a refusal to cover or pay — that is a "grievance" (a complaint), and it follows a different path. For complaints about quality of care, you can also contact your BFCC-QIO.
Appealing is free. Protect yourself.
Medicare and your plan do not charge a fee to file an appeal, and no company can file one for you faster for a price. Appeals go to the addresses printed on your own notices. A website or caller who asks for your Medicare Number and a credit card to "handle your appeal" is not Medicare. The real, free help is your SHIP (shiphelp.org) and 1-800-MEDICARE.
Why other pages give you different numbers
Websites disagree about Medicare appeals, and this page prints the disagreements rather than picking quietly:
- The Level 2 deadline. One seniors' advice site, seniorsinfo.org, prints 180 days on one of its pages and 120 days on another — for the same step. The CMS booklet says 180 days for the request to the Qualified Independent Contractor, and that is the figure on this page.
- "Small amounts can't be appealed." Another page suggests that if your disputed amount is under $200, you can skip levels. The booklet has no such rule. The $200 figure is the minimum amount needed to ask for a Level 3 judge hearing in 2026 — Levels 1 and 2 have no minimum at all.
- Older dollar amounts. Older copies of the booklet, and older web pages, print smaller amounts for Levels 3 and 5. The thresholds rise over time. This page uses the current booklet's 2026 figures: $200 and $1,960.
General information only — not legal advice. Appeal rules have many special cases (Cost Plans, PACE programs, and employer coverage among them) that this page does not cover. If your case is large or complicated, your SHIP can help for free, and a lawyer who works on Medicare cases can advise you. The booklet below is the government's own explanation, and it is worth reading in the original.
Sources
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Medicare Appeals, Product No. 11525 (Medicare.gov publication, PDF): an appeal is the action you can take if Medicare, your Medicare health plan, or your Medicare drug plan refuses to cover a service, supply, item, or drug, refuses to pay for one you already got, changes the amount you must pay, or stops a service, item, or drug you still need (including Part D drug-management "at-risk" limits); ask your provider for supporting information and keep copies of everything; there are generally 5 levels in each path. Original Medicare: the Medicare Summary Notice arrives at least every 6 months (monthly for electronic MSNs); Level 1 redetermination by the Medicare Administrative Contractor — file by the date on the MSN, with a good-cause exception for late filing, by circling items on an MSN copy, Form CMS-20027, or a written request with name, Medicare Number, items and dates, reason, and proof of representation; decisions generally within 60 days, extended 14 days per additional evidence submission. Level 2 reconsideration by the Qualified Independent Contractor within 180 days of the Level 1 decision (Form CMS-20033), decisions generally in about 60 days, with escalation to the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals (OMHA) if the QIC cannot finish in time. Advance Beneficiary Notice (Form CMS-R-131): choosing Option 2 or 3 means no appeal; related notices include the skilled nursing facility notice (CMS-10055), hospital-issued notices of noncoverage, and home health notices. Medicare health plans: organization determination timelines (72 hours for Part B drugs, 7 days for prior-authorization requests for items and services, 14 days for other requests, 60 days for payment requests; expedited decisions in 24 hours for Part B drugs and 72 hours for items and services when health could be seriously jeopardized); Level 1 plan reconsideration due within 65 days of the denial notice, with plan answers in 30 days (pre-service), 60 days (payment), 7 days (Part B drugs), or 72 hours (fast), plus a possible 14-day extension with notice; Level 2 Independent Review Entity review is automatic when the plan upholds its denial, with the same clocks. Medicare drug plans: written notice at the pharmacy; coverage determinations (including formulary, tiering, and prior-authorization/step-therapy/quantity exceptions) in 72 hours standard (exceptions: 72 hours from the doctor's supporting statement), 14 days for payment requests, 24 hours expedited (not available after payment); Level 1 plan redetermination within 65 days (72 hours fast, 7 days for benefit requests, 14 days for payment); Level 2 Independent Review Entity reconsideration within 65 days, with drug-management-program denials forwarded automatically. Levels 3–5 (all paths): OMHA Administrative Law Judge hearing requested within 60 days of the Level 2 decision, minimum amount in controversy $200 for 2026 (claims may be combined; Form OMHA-100; hearings usually by phone or video); Medicare Appeals Council within 60 days, any amount (Form DAB-101); federal district court within 60 days, minimum $1,960 for 2026, only after the Council decides against you or fails to decide in time. Fast appeals: hospital "Important Message" — request BFCC-QIO review by the day printed on the notice (no later than discharge), stay without extra charge beyond deductible and coinsurance while waiting, decision generally within 1 day of receiving information; other settings — notice at least 2 days before coverage ends, request by noon of the day before the end date, decision generally by close of business the day after information is received; inpatient-to-observation status changes have a separate fast appeal via the Medicare Change of Status Notice (Form CMS-10868), decision in about 2 days, run by the BFCC-QIOs (Livanta and Acentra). Representatives: appointment by Form CMS-1696 or an equivalent written request; doctors may act without appointment for certain plan and drug-plan requests. Grievances (complaints) are distinct from appeals. Help: 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), TTY 1-877-486-2048; State Health Insurance Assistance Programs (SHIP) at shiphelp.org give free counseling and appeal help. Read in full November 7, 2026.
The conflicting figures in the "Why other pages give you different numbers" section were seen on the named pages during this guide's research on November 7, 2026, and are printed with their sources so you can see why this page follows the CMS booklet instead.
Checked November 7, 2026.
Related guides: How to Get Medicare Letters in Large Print, How to Report Medicare Fraud, Medicare Annual Wellness Visit, Medicare Initial Enrollment Period and Medicare Late Enrollment Penalties.